Lindsay grew up in Florida and then moved to Knoxville, Tennessee where she attended church at Faith Lutheran and came to know Pastor Matt, his wife Melody, and Bill Porter. Before moving to Atlanta in January, 2011, Lindsay co-led worship for the contemporary service at Faith Lutheran and developed youth programming. Lindsay is also a nationally ranked vocalist who has toured extensively in Europe with the Sound of America honors band and choir. More significantly, in 5th grade, Lindsay wanted to be a fashion designer, and in the same year won second place at a bowling competition- she still has the trophy.